Mr Cricket UAE

The curious case of Mohammed Siraj’s absence in Wellington Test

Share
Mohammed Siraj

Mohammed Siraj (Source: Getty Images)

Rishabh Beniwal

Rishabh Beniwal

Published - 20 Nov 2026, 06:58 AM Read time - 10 mins

When India captain Shubman Gill walked out for the toss on Day 1 of the first Test against New Zealand at Basin Reserve, Wellington, he made a couple of big calls. Two of the most senior players of the current setup were dropped, namely Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja.

It was a big decision, given the stature of both players as well as their performances. Both Siraj and Jadeja are India’s top two wicket-takers of the current World Test Championship (WTC) 2025-27 cycle. Moreover, Jadeja also has the best batting average for Indian batters outside Asia post-2024 (54.25).

Most wickets for India in WTC cycle 2025-27

Name

Matches

Wickets

Mohammed Siraj

12 (23 innings)

44

Ravindra Jadeja

11 (21 innings)

33

Jasprit Bumrah

8 (14 innings)

33

Best Average for Indian batters outside Asia since 2024

Name

Runs

Average

100s/50s

Ravindra Jadeja

651

54.25

1/6

Shubman Gill

893

52.52

4/0

Rishabh Pant

734

45.87

2/4

KL Rahul

816

40.80

2/4

Yashasvi Jaiswal

830

39.52

3/4

“You know, very difficult for Siraj and Gurnoor for both of them to miss out, you know. They did decently well in the ODI series. Siraj and Gurnoor obviously, you know, was man of the series there. So it was a hard decision for us. But hopefully, you know, all the fast bowlers that we picked, they should be able to do the job for us,” said Gill at the toss.

Gill expected the bowlers to justify their selections, and they did for part of it, reducing New Zealand to 70/5 by the second session. However, after Glenn Phillips (118) and Henry Nicholls (175*) stitched a massive partnership of 216 runs for the sixth wicket, the bowling looked toothless.

Pace spearhead Jasprit Bumrah kept running in with not much support from Anshul Kamboj, Prasidh Krishna and Akash Deep. While Krishna leaked runs at an economy of over four, Kamboj’s pace dropped to 120s by the end of the day’s play. As a result, the questions over India’s bowling selections were raised further.

Don't think dropping Siraj was wrong decision: Sitanshu Kotak

"There is nothing wrong with Siraj. We thought this was the best XI when we picked the side. I don't think dropping Siraj was a wrong decision. This is just the first day. We don't pick a team only for day one, but also for days two, three and four," said India’s batting coach Sitanshu Kotak in the press conference after the end of the day’s play.

Kotak also explained the reasoning behind Washington Sundar’s selection over Ravindra Jadeja.

"We preferred Washy as their top order had four left-handers. For this match, this is the best possible bowling attack," he added.

Benching Siraj was something no one expected, especially after his heroic show on India’s last overseas tour in England. In the absence of Jasprit Bumrah, during the fifth Test at the Oval, Siraj was relentless and helped India register a narrow win by six runs to level the series 2-2.

While Siraj wasn’t at his best during the last Test series in Sri Lanka, given his experience and helpful conditions, he was considered an automatic selection in Wellington.

However, much to everyone’s surprise, India decided to drop their workhorse for less experienced bowlers. Despite that, Siraj was still seen giving his 100% on the field when he came on as a substitute, giving full support to the bowlers as Phillips and Nicholls frustrated India.

Whether the selection comes back to haunt India or proves right will be known in a few days. However, the treatment meted out to India’s consistent performers over the past few years has continued to raise questions about the current regime.